George Lucas’ Star Wars Films Show One Sequel Trilogy Criticism Improper

The Star Wars sequels have been criticized for the obvious lack of an general plan, however the historical past of the George Lucas Star Wars motion pictures means that planning the story upfront is just not all the time crucial for them to work. whereas Star Wars: The Drive Awakens‘ record-breaking field workplace efficiency indicated that Disney’s launch technique for the Star Wars sequels could be a assured success, neither Star Wars: The Final Jedi nor Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker was as profitable or as critically acclaimed. The Final Jedi flipped lots of what The Drive Awakens had arrange, whereas The Rise of Skywalker retconned lots from The Final Jediresulting in the conclusion that the sequel trilogy had not been mapped out upfront.


in The Drive AwakensJJ Abrams arrange many thriller packing containers for Episodes VIII and IX to select up. The largest instance was the thriller of who Rey’s mother and father had been, however The Drive Awakens additionally arrange questions relating to who Supreme Chief Snoke was, how the First Order got here to be, who had been the Knights of Ren, and the way precisely Luke Skywalker’s Jedi academy fell. Whereas these mysteries created thrilling prospects for the sequels, in addition they generated lots of expectations. The consequence was a really divisive The Final Jedia film that proved many widespread theories and speculations incorrect.

Associated: Lucas’ Unique Darth Vader Plan Would’ve Prevented A number of Sith Twists

The story of the Star Wars sequels turned extra sophisticated with The Rise of Skywalkerthe various essential reveals from The Final Jedi had been both reinterpreted or fully contradicted. Nonetheless, these inconsistencies among the many three installments had been a symptom of different issues with which the Star Wars sequels needed to deal, reminiscent of a strict launch window of two years between every film and modifications within the artistic group. The shortage of a road-map model plan, one within the likes of the MCU, could have contributed to the Star Wars sequels’ issues, but it surely’s not the principle causes behind the trilogy’s flaws. When contemplating the historical past of the Star Wars motion pictures, the dearth of an general plan by no means bought in the best way of excellent, outstanding movies. In truth, when George Lucas had probably the most well-planned trilogy, the Star Wars prequels, the flicks ended up being closely criticized.

George Lucas By no means Had A Strict Plan For Star Wars

as soon as Star Wars was renamed Star Wars: Episode IV – A New Hope forward of the discharge of The Empire Strikes AgainGeorge Lucas revealed that the story he had in thoughts for the Star Wars saga was a lot greater than what audiences had been at present watching. The Star Wars creator went on to say a number of instances that he had a complete prequel trilogy deliberate, and that the one cause why he made the Luke Skywalker movies first was the funds and expertise limitations. That may make it appear George Lucas all the time had a whole roadmap for what the Star Wars saga could be like, however the Star Wars prequels proved this was not the case. Earlier than the discharge of Return of the Jedi, Lucas briefed the film’s artistic group on what Anakin Skywalker’s backstory could be like. The define has vital variations from the story that was ultimately advised within the prequel trilogy.

For instance, there was no Jedi Council, no Qui-Gon Jinn, no Order 66, and it was Anakin himself who would kill many of the galaxy’s Jedi. Padmé would have survived the principle occasions of the flicks, and she or he would have Leia for a few years earlier than dying. The prequel trilogy turned out very completely different from George Lucas’ authentic define, which exhibits how not even the creator of Star Wars had set-in-stone plans for the flicks.

Some Of Star Wars Greatest Moments Had been Not Deliberate Forward

Darth Vader tells Luke he's his father in The Empire Strikes Back

The reveal that Darth Vader was Luke Skywalker’s father, maybe the most important plot twist in popular culture historical past, solely got here to be in the course of the remaining drafts of The Empire Strikes Again. That alone proves how the dearth of an early define for 3 movies can truly be one thing constructive for the franchise. There was nothing in The New Hope that made it unattainable for Darth Vader to be Luke’s father, however there was additionally no clear setup for that reveal within the film. Likewise, The “there may be one other” line was not meant to be about Leia, because it was solely within the Return of the Jedi script that Leia Skywalker turned a factor. Initially, the dynamic amongst Luke, Leia, and Han could be that of a love triangle, however not even the notorious kiss in The Empire Strikes Again prevented Lucas from deciding, on the final minute, that Leia could be a Skywalker.

Associated: Each Means Clone Wars Retcons The Star Wars Prequels

The Prequel Trilogy Had A Extra Constant Plan (& Nonetheless Had Flaws)

Star Wars Prequel Trilogy Feature

In comparison with the unique trilogy, the Star Wars prequels had been far more constant by way of planning. George Lucas wrote and directed the three installments, which averted any main change in tone and aesthetics. Not like in the course of the authentic trilogy, Georg Lucas knew precisely the place the story of the Star Wars prequels was heading– as the whole lot needed to culminate with Anakin’s transformation into Darth Vader and the loss of life of many of the Jedi. Nonetheless, the Star Wars prequel trilogy was met with lots of criticism, particularly the primary two installments.

The unhealthy reception of the prequels by each critics and audiences made Return of the Jedi‘s combined critiques appear nothing compared, proving that having a plan or not is just not what defines if a film trilogy shall be good. As well as, the actual fact George Lucas was principally the one artistic drive behind the Star Wars prequels is among the the reason why Episodes I, II, and III didn’t reside as much as the unique Star Wars trilogy, because the collaboration between Lucas and different filmmakers was very constructive for the Episodes IV, V, and SAW.

The Star Wars Sequels’ Issues Had been Extra Than Simply Lack Of Planning


Proper from the start, the Star Wars sequels had been confronted with behind-the-scenes points that may not have been dealt with in one of the best ways potential. For instance, The Drive Awakens‘ authentic script by Michael Arndt was virtually fully rewritten, and even with such a big change, the film saved its deliberate 2015 launch date. The Final Jedi‘s manufacturing went seemly higher, however then, Colin Trevorrow was fired from episode IX a few months earlier than Episode VIII hit theaters.

From then on, Lucasfilm needed to rework what would change into JJ Abrams’ The Rise of Skywalker whereas additionally coping with the divisive The Final Jedi reactions. The consequence was an episode IX that didn’t have its personal id, making all the opposite Star Wars sequels’ much more noticeable issues. Had Lucasfilm spent extra time on the event of every movie, even when on the expense of the deliberate launch dates, then the dearth of a roadmap kind of plan would have by no means prevented the Star Wars sequels from attaining their true potential. Lucasfilm is now taking its time with the following Star Wars motion pictures, hopefully, to keep away from comparable errors being made.

Subsequent: Why Rey & Kylo Ren Are Extra Highly effective Than Prequel Jedi (It is Yoda’s Fault)

  • Rogue Squadron (2023)Launch date: Dec 22, 2023

Molly Hopkins 90 Day Fiancé

90 Day Fiancé’s Molly’s Most Stunning Skintight Outfits After Weight Loss

About The Writer